Discussion about this post

User's avatar
JR's avatar

The author has delivered a powerful rendering of the last century's history in a manner that utterly dismantles the current narrative. In a compelling way, the author brings to life the deep truth about the Palestine Question and shines a light on the innumerable instances in which the Arabs chose badly. We are where we are in the region not because of colonialism but because of a centuries long desire to destroy the Jewish people. It's well past time for the world to wake up to this.

Laura Meizler's avatar

First really well written and informative!

After reading your article, I did a bit of research on the “occupation” word. I hadn’t realized that the occupation narrative — the story that Palestinian suffering begins and ends with Israeli control of the West Bank — was not born in the Middle East. It was manufactured in Moscow.

After World War II, the Soviet Union needed to destabilize America’s most reliable democratic ally in the region. So the KGB did not fight Israel with weapons. It fought with words. Ion Mihai Pacepa, the highest-ranking Soviet bloc intelligence officer ever to defect to the West, documented how Soviet operatives transformed a local Arab rejection movement into a global anti-colonial cause — dressing raw violence in language the Western left could not resist. Liberation. Colonialism. Occupation. Yasser Arafat, an Egyptian, was a product of this machinery.

The word “occupation” is the most successful piece of that propaganda. It collapses under one honest question: occupied since when, and by whom? Jordan held the West Bank from 1948 to 1967, expelling every Jew. No protests. No UN resolutions. No marches in London. “Occupation” entered the vocabulary only when Israel controlled the land. That is not a legal argument. It is a Soviet-designed political weapon.

Then Denmark ran the experiment. In 1992, it accepted Palestinian refugees and tracked them for thirty years. No occupation. No checkpoints. Full opportunity in one of the world’s most peaceful countries. The results directly contradicted the narrative. The problem had traveled across the Mediterranean and reproduced itself in Scandinavia.

Jordan expelled them. Lebanon expelled them. Kuwait expelled 300,000 overnight.

The occupation was never the explanation. It was always the excuse.

676 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?